By Andrew R. Duckworth
I have never had an issue with the term “myth.” One of the reasons I’ve never had an issue with it is that I actually understand what the term means. It’s only been relatively recently that we’ve utilized the term to mean “lie” or “untruth.” What is ironic about utilizing the term in such a way is that myth transmits some of the most profound truths imaginable. I need to make this clear from the onset: I do not utilize the term “myth” the way many do nowadays. The phrase “oh, it’s just a myth” is an objectively ignorant phrase no matter the tone attached to it. When I utilize the term “myth,” I mean that which is a sacred narrative, much the way Alan Dundes described it. And while I certainly have my share of disagreements with some of Alan Dundes’s sentiments, defining “myth” as “sacred narrative” is probably one of the most concise and precise ways of defining it. It cuts right to the point.
In the days we live in, there is much reflection on the Tower of Babel. Pope Leo XVI recently referenced it in Magnificas Humanitas, which I firmly believe should be required reading in educational institutions, regardless of creed. However, it is rather sad that it took something as powerful as AI to have us reflect on this story outside of religious spaces. For clarity, I’m Catholic, so this story does hold significance to me perhaps more so than it might those who do not subscribe to religious affiliation. However, I also firmly believe that there is something in the story that should resonate with everyone. Ultimately, our own striving for greatness will be our own undoing.
The story of the Tower of Babel, in many ways, isn’t about a tower at all. Location matters not. And perhaps, sometime in our distant history, there was a society who sought to build a tower to the heavens. Whether there actually was or not does not really matter. What matters is the underlying truth of the story, the truth that transcends things like the senses, history, facts, etc. When the poet sits down to write a poem, yes experiences are often used to communicate a truth. But the truth is not necessarily defined by those experiences. Often times, we communicate these truths through other means, perhaps means that might communicate a common relationship to the reader. And sometimes, these truths can take on a shape not even entirely familiar to the poet if one is to read it literally.
In the story of the Tower of Babel, a society in Babylon so propped up by their own ambition and pride seeks to build a tower to the heavens. God then confuses their tongues and scatters them upon the land. Some may view this story as just a story. Some might even view God as the bad guy in the story. For those, I would tell them to take a good look around. Whether we would love to admit it or not, this very narrative has everything to do with what we are currently experiencing in the world.
It wasn’t long ago that AI seemed like a pipe dream to many. There were many voices that even said at those times that such an achievement would never happen. And yet, here we are. Artificial Intelligence is here, regardless of whether we wanted it and what we once believed about it. And then we should also ask ourselves what the reason for AI was initially. Was it for prosperity? Was it for intelligence? I would argue that we have effectively created an entity that prevents both prosperity and intelligence. Adults rush to AI to do their job for them and students rush to AI to complete their homework. In both scenarios, we are putting our minds to waste, a complete disregard to thinking and humanity in general. Regardless of what you believe about the divine, about the life after, or if you don’t believe in the life after, this is a reality. AI is not making us more effective or intelligent. In fact, the reality is much graver. We have, instead, off-loaded our own intelligence and become lazier in the process.
And yet, we have tech leaders who still prop up AI as if it will be the savior of humanity, solving all of our problems, etc. We have been building the tower, so to speak, for some time. And finally, it appears, that tower might be nearing completion. I’m not sure we will want to know what comes next. But, rest assured, it will not be the outcome that we expect.
In some ways, we are living in the time of the Tower of Babel in our own way. To cast all of the blame onto AI would hardly be fair. For the better part of two decades, I have seen influencers come and go, touting the self and little else. It is sometimes accompanied by endless “success” as they define it, and sometimes accompanied by a downfall. And new generations have been trained to follow these influencers in lockstep, forgoing their own individuality in favor of whatever the influencers do, whatever they like, whatever trends they set, another instance of thought being sent to the wind. Before we knew it, kids were drinking bleach and speaking in ways that can barely be considered intelligible (to clarify, I am not using this to reference the confusing of tongues. Language evolves over time and it is just an unfortunate reality that “bet” and “it’s giving” have become commonplace phrases in the English language). To make matters worse, we are actually proud of these “accomplishments.” We wave them around, both social media use and AI usage, as badges of honor while not recognizing the overwhelming irony of it all.
So, what of the “scattering” and “confusing of tongues”? Interestingly enough, the thing that was supposed to make us more connected than ever, social media, has actually contributed to societies that are more defined by separation than connection. We retreat to our tribes, blast each other to oblivion with our words, and somehow claim to love each other at the end of the day. I recall the early days of social media. Things weren’t terribly different, but there was still at least the idea of social media as a tool to keep track of our friends and family, our various goings on, etc. That concept, it would seem, has gone out the window. It isn’t about friends and family anymore. It is about follows and views. However, this isn’t by accident. We would be fools to think that we are solely responsible for this taking place. Those that control the various social media platforms have crafted them around the algorithms. Psychological studies for some time have reported how just opening up a social media app can provide a dopamine hit.
The “tools,” as some call them, we clearly were not prepared for. And, perhaps, in that is one of the many lessons that the Tower of Babel can provide. Perhaps some things we will never be prepared for because we can’t possibly understand them or their impact on the human mind. And by the time we’ve noticed there is a problem, it is too late.
To be clear, the primary lesson of the Tower of Babel for the Catholic is a lesson in human pride and the false belief that humanity can be elevated to the position of God. It is, in a way, a reflection of what came before it in the Genesis story—the fall of humanity. However, one of the powers of myth is that it often transcends culture and creed. A powerful lesson can be extrapolated from the Tower of Babel that we should be mindful of our own thoughts, as individuals and as societies, and be wary of those thoughts that we can somehow craft our own human prosperity.
The Catholic in me would tell those who do not necessarily believe by this point to keep looking around. What does the rejection of a higher power offer other than turmoil and despair? Is it possible to prosper apart from belief in a higher power? I think there is a communication that takes place through the biblical texts that few others provide. These lessons aren’t just lessons. They aren’t something that you can see and then, just as quickly, discard. The biblical texts offer a challenge, one that the Christian must take up—one of seeing both the beauty of the world that God created but also the fallen nature of it by our own imperfections. If you are like me, you are far from perfect. Perhaps it is time to recognize that and not be proud of it, but reflect on it in a healthy way, one that can aim towards prosperity rather than despair.
The outcome of the Tower of Babel narrative is that those responsible found themselves in a world of no communication, one of loss. And I like to think that the story ends with those individuals not being angry or anxious beyond belief, but rather reflective. Should the world fall into chaos, would we recognize our errors? Would we be reflective? Would we attempt to understand that it was our own pride that brought it upon us? Or would we try to find someone else to blame? Myth gives us the questions. It is up to us to deal with them.