A short break… that turned into a long one…

Describe a failure that, looking back, was actually one of the best things that ever happened to you.

By Andrew R. Duckworth

I had completed my junior year of undergraduate at university. But I was getting tired. My printmaking instructor was the first that had ever failed me. It hadn’t been from lack of trying. I tried my hardest in that class, but other students seemed to catch on more than I did and the instructor was rather intimidating. I didn’t dare ask for further instruction or for her to even explain the processes, etc. But my failure of that one class in college led to a depression. I didn’t want to take printmaking, but it was a requirement in studio arts… Ridiculous.

Anyway, I was depressed and self-loathing, and, honestly, I was still trying to figure out how I would ever make a living with studio art. Yet, I was about to go into my senior year. If I could get through one more year, I would be done with it. But the questions I had, which far outweighed the answers, got the better of me. I decided to take a year off from school to re-evaluate my life and where I wanted to be after school.

That year turned into several years. And, after just the first, I felt as though I was a failure. If only I could have just managed another year, somehow pulled off making a passable grade in printmaking. But then, how happy would I be? Would I be able to make it on my own? Doubtful. That market was conflated when I was considering it. To be a successful artist, and by “successful” I mean able to put food on the table, you either have to teach the subject or have the sort of luck people dream of at casinos… or perhaps live in Santa Fe, NM. Regardless, if it wasn’t art, what would it be?

My entire life up until that point had been so certain. I was piss-poor in maths, despised anything physics or chemistry related because of it, and couldn’t think of anything I would be able to do with history… but then there was English. I loved poetry because it challenged me in a lot of ways. I loved classic literature, mythology, etc. Yet… English… what do you do with it? I wasn’t sure, although I was sure that I could probably do a lot more with a literature degree than a studio art degree.

It was several years before I went back for my bachelors, and during that several years were trials beyond belief. I completely fell away from my faith due to a number of things, occasionally turned to alcohol to “solve” my problems, and completely abandoned every friend I made in college. After a long string of hurt and bad decisions—heartbreaks, aimlessness, self loathing, the occasional thought of self-harm, being overall unproductive—it was time to do something that I could actually benefit from. I got back into school, got my bachelor’s degree in English and even went back for my Master’s.

I like to think that it took me tanking to the bottom. I was a privileged child. My parents ensured that I had a future when many grow up not so certain. Perhaps I needed to experience the bad, the truly bad, for once. Perhaps I needed to experience the possibility of failure, the idea that my life might not be as certain as I had once thought. And it was the motivation I needed.

In my last year of the Master’s program, I came back to the faith and found someone I could spend the rest of my life with. After graduation, which was completed in the first year of COVID, I secured employment at a high school teaching literature. In a lot of ways, it was always what I was supposed to do. Mum had been a teacher for over thirty years, and teaching something I love, poetry and literature, was a dream. To be able to help others thrive and watch students succeed is amazing.

Anyway, it’s something I will always be thankful for—the failure that woke me up from a long slumber so that I could finally thrive.

Leave a Reply